The International Textbook Alternative
by German Sanchez
February 24, 2010
Every semester the story is the same. Students purchase their textbooks and are reminded how expensive an education can be. It seems that book prices inflate every year. Thus, students have grown used to paying triple digit prices. After all, what alternatives are there?
A student can buy used books, but it is a hassle working with ravaged, withered, underlined, and highlighted collections of glued back pieces of paper. A few lucky students may get fortunate enough to avoid the ridiculous purchase prices of new books by purchasing substantially cheaper, hardly opened, used books. Having said that, if a student has to pay $150 for a book that originally cost $200, he or she is still paying in the triple digits.
Some students have stumbled across and have been pleasantly surprised by another solution: international edition textbooks. These books usually cost half, or less than half, of what a U.S. edition textbook costs. The most amazing thing about international edition textbooks is that they are the same as their U.S. counterparts.
Although international textbooks may look different from their U.S. counterparts, they feature the same content. The most obvious difference between a U.S. textbook and its international version is the cover. International textbooks usually are soft cover and portray a different cover image. Additionally, the paper in an international edition textbook is not the glossy commodity that publishers print U.S. editions in. A textbook’s most crucial element is the written knowledge that the books hold. Not only do international and U.S. print the same written knowledge, they print the same knowledge in the same prose, and in the same formatting. The author of a U.S. textbook also owns the international edition’s copyright and thus receives royalties from both editions.
If international editions are comparable to their U.S. counterparts, why are students reluctant to buy them? One possible explanation is the fear of being defrauded. International books are available online from third party sellers who sell the books on sites such as Amazon, EBay, AbeBooks, andValoreBooks. These books are not found in U.S. campus bookstores, nor are they available at your local Barnes & Noble.
The words “Not for Sale in the United States” that are printed alongside the titles is another factor that makes people reluctant to purchase international editions. This message scares U.S. consumers away because of copyright infringement and potential lawsuit nightmares.
There is good reason to fear the almighty copyright, so piracy should be discouraged. However, international books do not violate the law. In 2003, Tamar Lewin wrote a story on the copyright issue of international textbooks for the New York Times. Lewis notes that some students have taken it upon themselves to provide students with the cheaper international alternative. These students purchase a bundle of international books and sell them to other students in their campus.
There have been instances where companies have tried to block the importation of their products from countries where they are sold at substantially reduced prices. Lewin’s article refers to a supreme court decision made in Quality King Distributors, Inc. v. L’anza Research International, Inc. The case in question involved the re-importing of goods sold legally in foreign markets. “It appears that after L’anza’s United Kingdom distributor arranged for the sale of several tons of L’anza products, affixed with copyrighted labels, to a distributor in Malta, that distributor sold the goods to petitioner, which imported them back into this country without L’anza’s permission and then resold them at discounted prices to unauthorized retailers. L’anza filed suit, alleging that petitioner’s actions violated L’anza’s exclusive rights under the Copyright Act of 1976”.
The Court ruled against L’anza and found that “after the first sale of a copyrighted item lawfully made under this title,” any subsequent purchaser, whether from a domestic or from a foreign reseller, is an “owner” of that item. In simpler terms, the ruling states once an individual purchases a copyrighted material legally, it is his to do with what he will (except pirate said material), which includes selling, importing, or exporting.
The Supreme Court ruling established that the purchase and use of international edition textbooks is perfectly legal and a viable option for students. With that said, there is no reason why a student should not buy the less expensive versions of their textbooks. After all, why should student purchase U.S. editions at such insane prices?
Lastly, for any student who wishes to save cash next semester, the remainder of this article will briefly explain how to find international books.nte
The best place to find international books is online. Popular e-commerce websites and booksellers, like Amazon and EBay, offer international editions. There are also several websites that specifically cater to academia, such as abebooks.com, valorebooks.com, and textbooks.com. These websites also offer international editions from various individuals who sell them from their place of origin.
The easiest way to locate international books is to:
- Visit a specialized search site, like bigwords.com.
- Enter the U.S. edition ISBN# and run a search. BigWords runs a search of the major online textbook providers and displays a list of the various prices for new and used books.
- Scroll down the page to view the listed international editions of the books.
- Follow the links and secure your purchases. Each link comes with descriptions, pictures, and details about the seller. Most sites guarantee that their international books will have the same specifications as the U.S. books. The sites also usually handle disputes very well and promptly reimburse buyers who experience any problems.
rgument: Why not buy cheaper international textbooks?
Every semester the story is the same. Students purchase their textbooks and are reminded how expensive an education can be. It seems that book prices inflate every year.[RS1] Thus, students have grown used to paying triple digit prices. After all, what alternatives are there?
A student can buy used books, but it is a hassle working with ravaged, withered, underlined, and highlighted collections of glued back pieces of paper. A few lucky students may get fortunate enough to avoid the ridiculous purchase prices of new books by purchasing substantially cheaper, hardly opened, used books. Having said that, if a student has to pay $150 for a book that originally cost $200, he or she is still paying in the triple digits.
Some students have stumbled across and have been pleasantly surprised by another solution: international edition textbooks. These books usually cost half, or less than half, of what a U.S. edition textbook costs. The most amazing thing about international edition textbooks is that they are the same as their U.S. counterparts.
Although international textbooks may look different from their U.S. counterparts, they feature the same content.[RS2] The most obvious difference between a U.S. textbook and its international version is the cover. International textbooks usually are soft cover and portray a different cover image. Additionally, the paper in an international edition textbook is not the glossy commodity that publishers print U.S. editions in. A textbook’s most crucial element is the written knowledge that the books hold. Not only do international and U.S. print the same written knowledge, they print the same knowledge in the same prose, and in the same formatting. The author of a U.S. textbook also owns the international edition’s copyright and thus receives royalties from both editions.
If international editions are comparable to their U.S. counterparts, why are students reluctant to buy them? One possible explanation is the fear of being defrauded. International books are available online from third party sellers who sell the books on sites such as Amazon, EBay, AbeBooks, andValoreBooks. These books are not found in U.S. campus bookstores, nor are they available at your local Barnes & Noble.
The words “Not for Sale in the United States” that are printed alongside the titles is another factor that makes people reluctant to purchase international editions. This message scares U.S. consumers away because of copyright infringement and potential lawsuit nightmares.
There is good reason to fear the almighty copyright, so piracy should be discouraged. However, international books do not violate the law. In 2003, Tamar Lewin wrote a story on the copyright issue of international textbooks for the New York Times. Lewis notes that some students have taken it upon themselves to provide students with the cheaper international alternative. These students purchase a bundle of international books and sell them to other students in their campus.
There have been instances where companies have tried to block the importation of their products from countries where they are sold at substantially reduced prices. Lewin’s article refers to a supreme court decision made in Quality King Distributors, Inc. v. L’anza Research International, Inc. The case in question involved the re-importing of goods sold legally in foreign markets. “It appears that after L’anza’s United Kingdom distributor arranged for the sale of several tons of L’anza products, affixed with copyrighted labels, to a distributor in Malta, that distributor sold the goods to petitioner, which imported them back into this country without L’anza’s permission and then resold them at discounted prices to unauthorized retailers. L’anza filed suit, alleging that petitioner’s actions violated L’anza’s exclusive rights under the Copyright Act of 1976”.
The Court ruled against L’anza and found that “after the first sale of a copyrighted item lawfully made under this title,” any subsequent purchaser, whether from a domestic or from a foreign reseller, is an “owner” of that item. In simpler terms, the ruling states once an individual purchases a copyrighted material legally, it is his to do with what he will (except pirate said material), which includes selling, importing, or exporting.
The Supreme Court ruling established that the purchase and use of international edition textbooks is perfectly legal and a viable option for students. With that said, there is no reason why a student should not buy the less expensive versions of their textbooks. After all, why should student purchase U.S. editions at such insane prices?
Lastly, for any student who wishes to save cash next semester, the remainder of this article will briefly explain how to find international books.nte
The best place to find international books is online. Popular e-commerce websites and booksellers, like Amazon and EBay, offer international editions. There are also several websites that specifically cater to academia, such as abebooks.com, valorebooks.com, and textbooks.com. These websites also offer international editions from various individuals who sell them from their place of origin.
The easiest way to locate international books is to:
1. Visit a specialized search site, like bigwords.com.
2. Enter the U.S. edition ISBN# and run a search. BigWords runs a search of the major online textbook providers and displays a list of the various prices for new and used books.
3. Scroll down the page to view the listed international editions of the books.
4. Follow the links and secure your purchases. Each link comes with descriptions, pictures, and details about the seller. Most sites guarantee that their international books will have the same specifications as the U.S. books. The sites also usually handle disputes very well and promptly reimburse buyers who experience any problems.
[RS1]I removed doubled because that is a slight exaggeration. If that were the case, next year books would cost $300, then 600, then 1,200, etc.
[RS2]A tip: read sentences by themselves (without context) and ask yourself if they can stand alone. If they can’t, i.e. their subjects cannot be identified, then they should probably be rewritten. Who is “They”? International books? U.S books? Students?
Print
Lee Cannell February 25, 2010, 8:54 am
Great article. Good job.